Every taxpayer has the right to invoke previously declared income (capital consumption) that has been taxed or exempted from tax to cover a purchase or presumption. For the calculation of the capital consumption, the taxpayer may rely on a capital that had been formed in previous years, provided that they are continuous and extend to the previous year of consideration and that they can prove it.
Pursuant to Article 19, paragraph 2, case g of Law No. 2238/1994, the taxpayer may refer to a capital that formed in previous years when calculating the capital consumption. The capital of each year shall be determined by adding together
- the income that has been taxed or has been legally exempted from tax.
- The amounts of money that are not considered income.
- The amounts received from the disposal of assets
- Other amounts that are proven to have been demonstrably received (e.g., income earned as a minor and taxed on behalf of their parent´s name, to cover an expense incurred after the age of majority, unless such income had been invoked by the parent in the past, in order to cover this presumption, income declared by one of the spouses prior to cohabitation when they filed a separate declaration for their own income).
Determination of capital consumption
For the calculation of the capital consumption, the taxpayer can invoke a capital that had been formed in previous years in accordance with the more specific provisions that were in force in each case. The taxpayer can invoke a capital from previous years without limitation (Ministry of Finance 108712/2005), that is, also to a capital formed ten and fifteen years ago, under the following two conditions:
- It must have supporting documents from which the capital invoked for consumption can be derived.
- The years must be consecutive, for example, capital consumptions from the fiscal year 2004 to 2012, and not selective (e.g., capital consumptions from 2005 and 2009).
Someone claiming the consumption of income from prior years must include a statement showing from which years the claimed income was derived (Pol. 1040/2001).
Determination of capital consumption from 1/1/2010, which can be proven to have been taxed in previous years or to be exempt from tax by law
The case g of paragraph 2 of Article 19 of the ITC (which refers to the capital consumption of previous years) has been replaced by paragraph 7 of Article 3 of Law No.3842/2010 and applies to income and expenses incurred from 1/1/2010 and onwards. In particular, for the determination of the capital that the taxpayer can invoke each year, their actual income is taken into account, which:
- has been subject to taxation in accordance with the general provisions
- subject to independent taxation with the exhaustion of the tax liability (e.g., interest on deposits or bonds issued by the Greek State)
- is exempt from taxation by law (e.g., capital gains from the redemption of mutual funds units)
- the amounts of money that do not qualify as income:
-
- amounts of money derived from the disposal of assets,
- import of foreign currency, which is not mandatory to be assigned to the Bank of Greece,
- loans, donations, or parental provision of amounts of money for which the corresponding tax return has been submitted by the end of the year in which the corresponding expenditure was incurred
- any other amounts that can be proven to have been received, e.g., compensation for agricultural damage due to the destruction of the crops (subsidies received by the taxpayer under a development law for making investments are not covered).
From the above, income shall be deducted for the expenses, the determination of which is set forth by Articles 16 (objective expenses) and 17 (expenses for the acquisition of assets), regardless of whether they are exempt from the application of the presumption (Pol.1135/2010).
Negative incomes (damage)
According to the express wording of the law, negative income (damages) must be offset against positive ones, and the deduction of the expenses referred to, in Articles 16 and 17 of the Income Tax Code is made even if the taxpayer is exempt from them. For example, a disabled person who is exempt from the registration fees for the purchase of a passenger car, which is specially adapted for someone with a mobility disability of more than 67%.
If there are no objective expenses or the amount is smaller than 3.000 euros or 5.000 euros. In the event that there are no expenses under Article 16 of the ITC or if the amount of the existing expenses is smaller than three thousand euros (3.000) when it comes to single, divorced, or widowed persons. In case of spouses the amount is five thousand euros (5.000), ant the amounts are determined based on the social, financial and family situation of the taxpayers and the proven cost living will be deducted when determining the capital of previous years. These amounts cannot be in any case lower than three thousand (3.000) and five thousand (5.000) euros respectively.
Any amount that was paid to obtain the proceeds reduces them and the resulting balance is what limits or covers the total annual expenses (e.g., the proceeds from the sale of stocks or immovable property must be reduced by the cost of acquiring them if they were purchased, or by the gift tax, if they were acquired by donation, etc.). The exceptions are the cases where the cost of acquiring such income was taken into account as a presumption in determining the income of the year in which it was paid, and the taxpayer invokes the capital consumption for that year.
Example: If a taxpayer sells in 2012 real estate that was purchased for use in the year 2005 and invokes the income from the sale of the real estate for the coverage or limitation of the total annual expense, then the cost of acquiring the real estate must be deducted from the proceeds of the sale. This happens unless the purchase of the property was in the year 2005 when a presumption was purchased, and the taxpayer invokes the capital consumption from previous years, including the year 2005, in addition to the income from the sale.
Determination of capital consumption for the years 2008 and 2009 For the financial years 2009 and 2010 (use of 2008 and 2009)
Pursuant to the provisions of paragraph 4 of Article 3 of Law No.3763/2009, the expenses of Articles 16 (objective expenses) and 17 (expenses for the acquisition of assets) of the ITC shall be deducted when determining the capital of each year, only if they fall under the provisions on the application of the presumption and are not exempt.
Example: If a natural person owned a car in 2008 and 2009 that was exempt from the presumption (e.g., factory value of fewer than 50.000 euros), and during 2012 the capital consumption of the two previous years is invoked then the presumed expenses of the car in question will not be deducted. Given that the person is exempt from the presumption that there are no living expenses under Article 16 of the ITC or that the amount is smaller than 2.900 euros, an amount of at least 2.900 euros will be deducted.
Any amount paid to obtain this income shall reduce it so that it can be taken into account for the coverage or the limitation of the total annual expenditure unless these amounts have been taken into account in determining the income of the year in which they were paid, and the taxpayer invokes the capital consumption for that year.
Determination of capital consumption for uses from 1/1/2005 to 31/12/2007
In determining the capital for each year, the following factors are taken into account:
- the real income that has been taxed or has been legally exempt from tax, which results from the netting of these positive and negative elements,
- the amounts of money that are not considered income:
-
- the amounts of money derived from the disposal of assets.
- the importation of foreign currencies that are not compulsorily assignable to the Bank of Greece.
- loans, donations, or parental provision of amounts of money for which the relevant tax return has been submitted by the end of the year in which the relevant expenditure was incurred and any other amount that has been proven to have been received.
From the above, incomes are deducted from the expenses whose determination is defined by Articles 16 (objective expenses) and 17 (asset acquisition expenses), regardless of whether they are exempt from the application of the presumption.
Example: A natural person in 2012 was the owner of a car that was excluded from the presumption (e.g., factory value of fewer than 50.000 euros) for the period 2005-2009. This person invokes the capital consumption of the two previous years for the financial years 2006, 2007, 2008 (use in 2005, 2006, 2007) and thus the presumptive expenses for the car in question will be deducted despite the fact that during these years the presumption did not apply. For the financial years 2009 and 2010 though (use in 2008, 2009) the amount is not deducted because it is exempt from the presumption.
Attention: Starting from 1/1/2005 until 31/12/2007, when determining the capital of each year and, more specifically, when deducting the presumptive living expenses and the acquisition of assets, these expenses are deducted, regardless of whether they are exempt from the application of the presumption.
Determination of capital consumption for uses from 1/1/1992 to 31/12/2004
In determining the capital for each year, the following factors are taken into account:
- the real income that has been taxed or has been legally exempt from tax, which results from the netting of these positive and negative elements
- the amounts of money that are not considered income:
-
- the amounts of money derived from the disposal of assets.
- the importation of foreign currencies that are not compulsorily assignable to the Bank of Greece.
- loans, donations, or parental provision of amounts of money for which the relevant tax return has been submitted by the end of the year in which the relevant expenditure was incurred
- any other amount that has been demonstrably collected.
From the above, incomes are deducted from the expenses whose determination is defined by Articles 16 (objective expenses) and 17 (asset acquisition expenses), as applicable, regardless of whether they are exempt from the application of the presumption.
In the event that there are no expenses on the basis of Article 16 or their amount is smaller than two thousand nine hundred (2.900) euros, the amount that must be deducted and can in no instance be lower than two thousand nine hundred (2.900) euros.
Instead, it must be determined based on the social, financial, and family situation of the taxpayers and of their proven living expenses
Any amount that was paid to obtain this income reduces the expenses in order for them to be taken into account for the coverage or the limitation of the total annual expenditure unless these amounts have been taken into account in the determination of the income of the year they were paid, and the taxpayer invokes capital consumption for this year.
Determination of capital consumption for the financial years 1992 and earlier
For the determination of the funds for the financial years 1992 and earlier, the decrees that were in force during the relevant financial years are applied (POL. 1042/92). In summary:
A. Appropriation of funds throughout the financial year 1978
Incomes that are taken into account:
- Taxable and tax-free income, as well as the amounts of money from the sale of assets are taken into account etc.
- The living expenses and the amounts allocated for the purchase of assets, for life insurance premiums, and the payment of taxes are deducted, etc. (Reg. 7/22-1-1979)
- The remaining balance constitutes the capital for consumption
B. Appropriation of funds from the financial year 1979 through the fiscal year 1988
- Initially, the total net income is determined by netting positive and negative items that are declared taxable or exempt.
- The capital consumed is obtained by subtracting the expenses referred to in Articles 11 and 12 of Law No.820/78 from the declared total net income.
C. Appropriation of funds from the financial year 1989 through the fiscal year 1992
From the declared incomes, we subtract the tax-free amounts under paragraphs 3 and 4 of Article 8 of Law No.3323/55. We also subtract the expenses of paragraphs 6, 7, and 11 and the corresponding tax or the total of the assumed expenses of paragraph 2-4 of Article 5 of Law No.3323 as amended by Article 5 of Law No. 1828/89. This depends on which is more significant (if the total of the assumed costs is the highest, then we subtract it).
D. Abolition of savings that were formed by the declaration (form E6 of the financial year 1992)
It is also pointed out, that the provisions of Article 10 of Law No.2019/1992, which established the obligation to submit the form E6 (declaration of movable assets that you had owned on 1.1.1991), which you had attached to the declaration for the financial year 1992, do not apply to the amounts of actual and imputed expenses that were incurred from 1/1/1994 onwards.
As a result, the amounts of money that were claimed from the consumption or sale of these items, in consideration of the sums that were taken into account to reduce the added presumptive difference of the financial years 1992 to 1994, have affected the amounts of the funds of the corresponding years, which can be invoked to reduce the presumption.
Attention: If the amounts of money written in the codes 781-782 and 787-788 come from assets that were acquired after 1/1/1988, they must be reduced by any amount that was paid for their acquisition. This will not happen if these amounts have been taken into account when determining the capital of the year they were paid, the consumption of which the taxpayer claims with the declaration of the financial year 2013.
Capital from previous years from the income of a minor that had been taxed in the name of the father
The taxpayer can claim consumption of his income that was earned when he was a minor and was taxed in his parent’s name for the coverage of an expense incurred after reaching the age of majority, unless that income had been invoked by the parent in the past in order to cover this presumption (POL. 1259/2-11-2000).
Coverage of presumptive purchase, spouses with funds from previous years, before the start of their married life
In the years when the married cohabitation had not begun, and each spouse submitted a separate declaration for their own income, the income of each spouse can be used to cover, or reduce only their own, as the case may be, added presumptive difference (POL. 1094/23-3-89).
Coverage of the added difference of presumptions with capital consumption of previous years between spouses who are separated
The spouses who submit the income tax returns separately because of separation can, according to Article 19 of the ITC, invoke funds from previous years for coverage of their presumption. These funds can only come from their own incomes and not from the family income that arose during the married life (Relevant document 1020051/389/Α0012/12-3-2002 and 1048601/935/Α0012/8-6-2005).
Coverage of the surviving spouse’s presumption of income declared on joint tax returns
If the wife who submits a separate tax return for her own income, (because of the death of her husband) wishes to cover in the future a presumption of purchase of immovable property using the capital consumption of previous years, she can rely on her own incomes and on the incomes of her husband included in their joint declarations (Relevant document 100180711/8-1-2003).
Coverage of presumption by capital consumption of previous years. Non-recognition of damage in case of determination of income on the basis of the annual expenditure
When the determination of the income is based on the annual expenditure of Article 19 of the ITC, the damage of the same financial year or the previous ones is not deducted, and neither is it transferred for netting in the following financial years.
In the event that the determination of income occurs in any year based on the presumptions, any resulting damage in that year is not offset against the remaining income nor carried over to subsequent years. Therefore, when using capital from previous years, the damage from this year will not be taken into account.
If, in any of the past years in which the taxpayer invokes capital consumption, there is damage from a commercial enterprise, this damage is, in principle, offset against the remaining income of the taxpayer. In the event that the final result after the offsetting remains negative when determining the capital of previous years, the final damage of this year is not taken into account as a deduction, but for this year, it is considered that there is no capital left for consumption (Relevant document 1045929/856/Α0012/19-5-2005).
Tax audit difference
In the event of a tax audit of previous financial years, for which the taxpayer invokes capital consumption, the final incomes of the settlement are taken into account.
No penalty for submitting a supplementary declaration for incomes that are exempt from taxation or taxed in a special way or are not considered income
When the taxpayer submits a supplementary declaration and declares income that is taxed in a different way or is exempt from tax or amounts of money that are not considered income, no fine is imposed on him (POL. 1317/2-12-1997).
It is possible for the additional declarations of income to be accepted, provided that the right of the public to impose tax has not expired. If the statute of limitations has expired, the supplementary declarations are not taken into account when forming capital to cover the presumption. (Ministry of Finance 1082131-3/10/2001).
Documentation of the capital consumption of previous years
To cover the assumed cost of living and the acquisition of assets by capital consumption from previous years, a detailed table is submitted. In this table the data of the income can be found (income, donations, etc.) and also the annual expenditures of assumptions or an amount of 2.900/3000/5000 euros, as the minimum amount of living expenses when there are no expenses (presumptions). This happens according to Article 16 depending on the year that it is invoked. Declared incomes for consumption with the amount of the capital formed every year are intended to cover presumptions.
Addition of the difference between total annual expenditure and total declared income, in the final reported income
In the event that the real incomes that are declared by the husband, the wife, and the members of his family who live together, and burden the husband, are smaller than the presumed income, then the difference increases the incomes reported by the taxpayer or his wife. More specifically, when these incomes come from commercial enterprises (income from source D), or liberal professions (income from source G). If they do not declare income from these sources then the whole difference is considered income, under paragraph 3 of Article 48 of Law No. 2238/94 (incomes that cannot be attributed to another source), and it is taxed in the name of the taxpayer or his spouse, depending on to whose detriment the difference is.
The difference between the total annual objective expenditure, and the total income that was declared by one spouse, can be covered by the income of the other spouse
In the case where the objective expenditures of one spouse are more than the income that was declared by them (and the persons for whom they are responsible) and the resulting difference is not covered by other incomes declared by them in table 6 of the declaration, then the difference can be covered by the incomes of the other spouse.
Steps that we follow for the calculation of the difference between the total income and presumptions
- We find the total net family income.
We aggregate the individual net incomes as declared in Table 4, which are taxed in accordance with the general provisions about taxing income with the offsetting of the positive and negative elements. As part of this aggregation, income declared in Table 6 will not be taken into account, which is exempt from the tax or is taxable independently of the exhaustion of the tax obligations.
- We find the family’s total simulated income.
We sum up the individual presumptions of living and the acquisition of assets, as they are presented in Table 5.
- We find the difference between the actual and imputed income.
- We find the income that covers or limits the difference.
We add up the incomes declared in Table 6 of the declaration as exempt, taxed in a special way, etc., net amounts derived from the sale of assets, loans, donations, parental allowances of foreign exchange, etc., and capital consumption. If these incomes are greater than the difference of the presumption, then they cover the difference, and therefore no amount is charged to the actual income. However, if they are less than the difference of the presumption, then the final difference left uncovered is added to the taxable income.
Example: A taxpayer running a sole commercial proprietorship in the year 2012 declares net profits of 40.000 euros, a net rental income from property rental of 10.000 euros (after depreciation and expense deductions), meaning a total net income of 50.000 euros (40.000 + 10.000). In addition, in the same use, there is an objective expenditure from T.I.R. at 20.000 and from buying a store of 100.000, i.e., a total expenditure of 120.000 euros (20.000 + 100.000). Comparison between actual income and objective expenses.
Total declared real income = 50.000
Total objective expenditure = 120.000
Difference: 70.000
If the taxpayer cannot justify the amounts of money for the total objective expenditure (living and acquisition of assets), then the difference of 70.000 euros will be added to the income from commercial enterprises and the taxpayer will be taxed on income from commercial enterprises of 110.000 euros (40.000 + 70.000), plus real estate income of 10.000 euros, i.e., the total taxable income of 120.000 euros (110.000 + 10.000).


